Message Us

A Secret Insight Into How Dogs Learn!

By TracyKrulik. | Dog Training

My friend Anna looked exhausted when she complained to me about her yellow Lab. "Ainsley is so stubborn," Anna said. "She pees all over the house, when I know she knows not to do it, and she won't even sit when I tell her to."

  How Dogs Learn and Follow Your Commands! "Have you trained her to sit?" I asked. "Yes!" Anna responded. "She learned it in puppy class." "Oh cool. So, do you still give her treats when she sits now?" "No. Of course not. We already did that," she said. "I shouldn't have to bribe her. She learned how to sit two months ago and is just refusing to do it now." "What about housetraining?" I asked. "Do you give her treats each time she goes to the bathroom outside?" "Yes! I always give her a cookie when we get back to the front door after a walk." I have conversations like this all the time. Most of the time, the pups in question aren't actually being willfully disobedient"”they simply don't understand what they're being asked to do. There is a science to animal learning, but even though trainers have been using it to teach parrots and dolphins and sea lions to perform for audiences since the middle of the 20th century, many dog guardians haven't yet learned about it. Armed with that knowledge, however, our relationship with our pups can vastly improve"”it's almost like we learn to speak a common language. Unlike us, dogs don't learn from reasoning and explanations. Instead, they learn what to do and what not to do through "operant conditioning." Like all animals, dogs learn from the consequences of their actions. Simply put, they do what works. If I give my Beagle, Emma, a treat each time she puts her tush on the ground, the next time I say "sit," she will sit. Tush on ground equals treat in mouth? Win! If I close the door each time Emma charges ahead to sprint outside, and only open the door for her when she pauses, she will learn to calmly wait for me to open the door. Stop moving forward and door opens up? Got it! In both of these scenarios, the consequences are something Emma wants. In the first one, it's food. She sits down; she gets a treat. So she's more likely to sit the next time I ask. In the second example, it's the backyard. She really wants to go outside, but that can only happen when she waits politely. The more repetitions of "sit equals treat" and "pause equals backyard," the more likely it will be that Emma continues those behaviors.

Dogs must be reinforced"”or "paid""”for doing the behavior we want them to perform, or the behavior will stop.

  Reinforcement can come in the form of chicken or cheese or tug toys or a game of fetch or walkies"”whatever the dog wants at that moment. But without reinforcement, over time the dog will stop doing the behavior"”a process known as "extinction." It's not stubbornness; it's science. Circling back to my friend Anna, the reason that Ainsley stopped sitting on cue is because the reinforcement stopped. Once Anna started giving Ainsley treats again for sitting, she sat. The housetraining issue is a little trickier. The reinforcer was there, but the timing was off. The treat must be given to Ainsley right when the behavior occurs, or Ainsley will associate the payment with something else. In this case, Ainsley associated getting home with the good stuff"”not peeing. To teach Ainsley to pee outside, Anna needed to give her the tasty treat just as Ainsley finished doing her thing. Before I understood how dogs learn, I was as frustrated as Anna. But once I started seeing food as a reinforcer rather than a bribe, my relationship with Emma has flourished. She now sits when I ask, walks politely on-leash, and even stops at intersections when I say "wait." We're speaking the same language finally, and the only cost to me is a pocketful of tasty treats to thank Emma for being such a good girl. How Dogs Learn and Follow Your Commands!

tracy krulikTracy Krulik

Tracy Krulik writes for publications including The Bark, The Washington Post, Washington Post Express, and the Association of Professional Dog Trainers' Chronicle of the Dog. She is also a student in Jean Donaldson's Academy for Dog Trainers. Visit her blog Dogz and Their Peoplez to read more.


Signup/Login to post a reply


Reviews From 4Knines Customers VIEW MORE »

The best evaluations of our products come from the people who’ve bought them.

bought two of these

Searched for different ones, decided on this one. Exceeded all expectations. Bought one for a new care and another for our 2004 4 runner. Provides good protection for vehicle and our 140 dog. We travel and camp extensively also good for bringing thing back form garden shop.

George Linhardt

Great product!

Does exactly what we wanted. We can easily raise a part of the seat to give our dogs better access to the rear seat of our pickup. And it's easily removed or installed when we need to put humans back there!

Michael Dean

Back Seat Cover for Subaru Impreza

Excellent quality and great customer service!

Alex Garcia-Osuna

Great covers

Not only are they great covers, 4knines has great customer service. Truly deserving of more than five stars.

Carmela DiCristofano

Great Cover - Great Company

The covers are absolutely the best and I have had quite a few over the years. I had a minor issue with my cover and asked if I could get it repaired. The response was: "Thank you for reaching out to us. Your cover is absolutely covered by 4Knines Lifetime Warranty!" I received a new one.

Bud Conner


This liner was so easy to install!! I love the way it fits and looks. My puppy also loves it.

Susan Frick

dog loves it

i don't have to fuss a the dog for clawing the door panels,a much more enjoyable ride for both of us.

Steven Walker

Perfect gift

I purchased this rear bench cover for a friend with two dogs that frequently accompany her to her barn. No problem with wet, muddy feet. Fits well and protects her investment in her car. The cover arrived promptly as promised.

Maribeth Hartin

For all general inquiries, please call or email us
Phone: 888.602.2509

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Nothing but the best for your best friend!
© 4Knines. 2017. All rights reserved | Terms | Privacy